Hometown Property Management ServicesHometown Props
227 North Duke Street Lancaster, PA 17602(717) 617-2108
sidewalk and yard with tree in front of a city home

3 Ways Landlords Evaluate Prospective Tenants

HTPMSadmin • July 22, 2010

I recently placed a nice city home for rent and had a great response. Within 4 days, I had shown the house 15 times and received 7 applications, ending with a signed lease. There were another dozen inquiries that I turned away because of the massive interest in this property. The rental market is hot, and renters are competing with each other for nice places.

This latest experience had me thinking. How do I choose someone when I have several qualified applicants? Hopefully, my thoughts help you the next time you’re looking for your next place. Or, for you landlords out there, perhaps an idea or two for when you evaluate prospective tenants. Here are some of the ways landlords evaluate prospective tenants:

1. First Meeting

Just like a job interview, that first impression is everything. Be on time. I recently met with my newest client, and he said to me that if I had shown up dressed too casually or smelling like a hoagie, he would have never hired me.

Don’t show up looking like a mess or smelling like a hoagie. Sure, the last place you came from may have been way less than standard for you. But this next one might be THE place! You need to engage with the person showing the property to you and be friendly, because when you leave, that landlord will have that first impression in their head. And in this competitive market, a good first impression and good first meeting are what you want.

2. Credit

Obviously, if you have good credit, good for you. But some people just don’t have ideal credit, and many landlords, like myself, do a full background check, which can include a credit and/or criminal check.

If your credit is less than desirable, it is not necessarily a deal-breaker. Don’t say, “My credit is terrible!” Instead say, “My credit is not as good as I’d like it to be. I’m working on it and completely focused on it. I hope you keep that in mind.”

Offer supplemental information, such as bank statements, references from old landlords, and anything else you have that will help show a prospective landlord that you are capable of paying rent consistently, have a history of paying on time, and will be a good tenant.

3. Income

Think about what is affordable for you because a landlord may look at your income and evaluate you on it. If they think that, with rent and expenses (along with your other monthly obligations), what you bring home every month is going to be a stretch, they may pass on you.

Apartments are priced on location, size, quality, and amenities. If you need to sacrifice one of these items to make your income fit more with what a landlord is expecting, do it. If you feel you need to prove to a landlord that you can afford the rent, again, bring items like savings account information or references. Landlords look at your overall financial situation. Their job is to make sure that you can pay the rent and pay it on time.

Good Tenant Placement and Screening Are Essential

If you have a landlord who you think could use help with this process, pass along this article to them or have them reach out to us; we’d be happy to help. Our experienced team, robust tenant screening process, and more are why clients choose Hometown.

If you’re a landlord and you struggle with finding tenants, or your property management company struggles to fill your vacancies in a timely manner, drop us a line. We’re known for filling vacancies quickly and efficiently, and for our low delinquency rate that is consistently below the industry average. Whether you’re interested in full-service property management or a standalone tenant placement service, Hometown can help!